Dear Commissioner Stewart and Members of the SCPS School Board,
My boys -7th and 8th graders- came home from Teague Middle School today saying that they will be on testing schedule Thursday and Friday because they have to take the FSA Writing “pre-test” or “benchmark” or whatever it is being called. First of all, I heard from teachers that this was coming but I was hoping that by some bit of grace that maybe we would escape it.
It is the tenth week of school. I know that the state is spinning this as an assessment so that teachers will know from where the students are starting. But again, it’s the 10th week of school. Every single ELA teacher in the county has done their own assessments (which have been valid for years) well prior to the 50th day of school. And my boys have AMAZING ELA teachers and I trust them implicitly. The over use of standardized testing is telling the teachers that you do not trust their judgement, experience, or education to assess their students on their own. Big data rules. Our kids and teachers are reduced to nothing but numbers.
This test is not on the official “Seminole County Testing Schedule” nor the State of Florida Department of Education Testing Schedule. I fully understand that the district is under legal obligation to administer the assessments that are put forth by the state. I also know that SCPS has been in contact with the state concerning high-stakes testing. So with that, Commissioner Stewart, I ask you, personally, not your testing office as you did this summer (who did not even know how many tests 4th graders would be taking this year), do you fully understand how this insane amount of testing plays out with our students, our children, MY KIDS?
Let me tell you. My 7th and 8th graders are both in Algebra I this year. The curriculum is for approximately 180 days, however the EOC for Algebra I could take place as early as April 20. That is 4.5 weeks before the end of school. That is one-eighth of the school year remaining. That is NOT the end of course. And since the EOC counts nearly as much as an entire semester of work (30% for EOC, 35% for each semester) that means that the teacher must review with them and prepare them for the test. So will they be forced to wrap up class by April 1? How exactly is a teacher NOT supposed to teach to the test when they are using a brand new “rigorous” curriculum with less time to teach it and to top it off, make that test count essentially ⅓ of their yearly grade? If the students do not understand something, there is no time to reteach it. They often cover two lessons in one day. Algebra is the basis for all upper level maths. This is a major problem; they NEED a strong base. My 7th grader is 12. Do not spew the nonsense of “career and college ready.” One bad day and an entire year’s worth of work (getting an A) could be shot.
Now you add an extra, off the “testing calendar” test that will not be used for any diagnostic purpose, but will only collect data for your precious VAM and my kids will lose even more instructional time. And not to mention, we had 9 week exams just last week. They had six big tests each and now the state is forcing them into yet another test. Why could this not be given in Language Arts as a normal prompt that they could work on for a few periods? Why are we disrupting two full days?
Over the summer your office blamed the district and then the legislature. I’m tired of the buck being passed. Mrs. Stewart, you are the one who is supposed to stand up for education, you are the one who is supposed to cultivate an atmosphere of the love of life-long learning in our schools. The buck stops with you. You are creating a bunch of little robots who can do nothing but take tests, you are squashing the love of learning and reading with which we parents sent them to school.
These are my babies, I love them, they are my heart. They have ONE childhood. ONE shot at a fabulous education and all you see them as is pawns in your high stakes testing game. Two ways to line the pockets of Pearson and AIR.
More rigor with less instruction and more testing is a recipe for disaster. Pull back on the high-stakes testing now. Delay the repercussions until or if we (not just you and the legislature, but the parents and teachers) can actually consider the FSA as a valid measure of education in Florida.
I look forward to your response,
Lynne Rigby